The Future of NASA
Michael Griffin is gearin...
More Features
Looking to apply for a Discover Credit Card? Members/Subscribers Log In      
Farewell
My Problem with Big Pharma
Has Newsweek Sold Out to Big Pharma?
Dark Side of Green, Continued
The Dark Side of Green
The Green Bandwagon
Green Book Award: Nominations Wanted
Wilson Wins “Green Book Award”
The End of Total War?
Does the Desire for Peace Cause War?
[ Full Blog Archives ]
[ Who is John Horgan? ]
[ What is Horganism? ]
Mind & Brain
Medicine
Space
Technology
Ancient Life
Environment
All Newsletters
   
Discover Magazine  Blog  Archives
Horganism

« Should Writers on Religion Disclose Their Beliefs? | Main | Is Religion a Spandrel? »



Is Religion the Inverse of Autism?

I’d like to elaborate on one of the theories of religion discussed in “The God Experiments.” The anthropologist Stewart Guthrie proposes that religious experiences—and particularly those involving visions or intuitions of a personal God--may stem from our innate tendency toward anthropomorphism, “the attribution of human characteristics to nonhuman things or events.” Guthrie called his book on this theory Faces in the Clouds, but he could have called it Jesus in the Tortilla.

Recent findings in developmental psychology dovetail with Guthrie’s theory. By the age of three or four all healthy children manifest an apparently innate ability to infer the state of mind of other people. This so-called theory-of-mind capacity has obvious survival value, because it helps us predict the actions of others for our own benefit. Psychologists postulate that autism stems from a malfunction of the theory-of-mind module. Autistics have difficulty inferring others’ thoughts, and even see no fundamental distinction between people and inanimate objects, such as chairs or tables. That is why autism is sometimes called “mind-blindness.”

Neuroscientists have linked autism with damage to the amygdala, which underpins emotion and social interactions, and to mirror neurons, which help us distinguish between ourselves and others. (See my post “Autism and ‘Mirror Neurons’”.) But many of us have the opposite problem—an overactive theory-of-mind capacity, which leads to what the psychologist Justin Barrett calls “hyperactive agent detection.” When we see squares and triangles moving around a screen, we cannot help but see the squares “chasing” the triangles, or vice versa, even when we are told that the movements are random. For the same reason, many of us intuit divine intentions behind hurricanes, earthquakes, shooting stars, rainbows, tsunamis, sporting events, Presidential elections and even suicidal attacks on skyscrapers.

In other words, religion may be the pathological inverse--the mirror image--of autism. But does that mean belief in God is always a delusion, as Richard Dawkins argues? More later.

Comments

bill

I guess a working definition of God would be in order. Those that think their brand of religion, say Christianity, is compatible w/ Science(evolution), may want to rethink what that actually entails. As Natalie Angier pointed out in her essay, My God Problem, this sort of consilience doesn't really work. A virgin birth is an act of parthenogenesis that defies everything we know about mammalian genetics and reproduction. Are christians ready to jettison this belief along w/ the resurrection?

Or are we talking about the mystical side of religions: the cloud of unknowing, advaita, or zen. Where the objective is to examine the psychological self for substance, which coincides w/ what some neuroscientists and psychologists aim to do.

endless_science

Doesn't it seem like the height of presumption to think that we, with the most minimal understanding of our *own* behaviors, could possibly begin to understand Divine intention?

You want to make a world free of war? Make psychology classes a mandatory part of high school education.

Comstock

I do think the human tendency to attribute human characteristics to non-human events and things is part of what motivates religion. But I think something is missing from that explanation. Religious thinking not only blames hurricanes on God, it often claims some sense of one-ness or connectedness with the world/universe. I've seen and read enough to suggest that the human brain also produces this effect. Maybe it is a by-product of some bonding behavior? Maybe some people have a hyperactive one-ness module in their brains, which leads them to religious feelings. It is not hard to imagine how some people could attribute this entirely natural phenomenon to God, just like the hurricane.

The_Iceman

Given the thesis that a predisposition to acceptance of religious explanations as a cause of various events, represents "...the mirror image--of autism," the reported presence of Asperger's syndrome in such geographic areas as Silicon Valley could provide a ripe source for validation of this hypothesis.

Silberman, in his Wired article (Issue 9.1, December 2001) The Geek Syndrome, reports a rapidly increasing frequency of Asperger's in the children of those involved in technology professions, particularly concentrated in Silicon Valley.

Asperger's presents behavioral attributes readily determined by survey. Personality attributes, educational attainment, and employment experience vs. level of religious belief could prove a fruitful line of discovery.

John Horgan

Iceman, did you see my post "Are Scientists More Likely to Have Autistic Kids?" at https://discovermagazine.typepad.com/horganism/2006/10/are_scientists_.html?
It describes a theory that autism is merely an extreme case of the "systemizer" personality, the opposite of which is the "empathizer." I agree it should be possible to test whether systemizers--including people with Asperger's syndrome--are less likely to be religious, spiritual, whatever. I'm pretty sure how that study would turn out, but I'd love to see real data.

Sandeep Gautam

I guess the hypothesis that religiosity is the mirror image of Autism, is compatible with my own schizophrenia as a mirror image of autism.

I've already highlighted the too-much-anthropomorphism/intent/causality skew in Schizophrenia vs the tendency toward seeing animals as no distinct from things in Autism. Combine this with the broad and loose associations of Schizophrenia and you have a framework for feeling of connectedness with universe, an anthropomorphic god and in general the god delusion. Interesting to note that delusions are a characteristic symptom of schizophrenia and many of them suffer grandiose, religious beliefs.

My post (https://the-mouse-trap.blogspot.com/2006/11/scizophrenia-and-autism-two-cultures.html) Autism vs Schizophrenia explores exactly that dimension, while a latter post (https://the-mouse-trap.blogspot.com/2006/11/two-cultures-continued.html) Two cultures continued explores the different incidences of schizophrenia and Autism in the American and east Asian culture. (which definitely also have different views toward religiosity/ spirituality.

Hal K

There is another aspect of this connection between "inverse" autism and religious belief, which is that for many people religious belief is reinforced socially by membership in and interaction with a group of other people (something that would tend to have less of an effect on someone with autistic tendencies).

Perhaps a person with autistic tendencies could still be religious if he/she associated that religious belief with a close bond formed with another person early in life.

Sandeep's links don't work unless you delete the right parentheses in the links, by the way.

The comments to this entry are closed.



   
Wishful Seeing
Shiny Happy People
20 Things You Didn't Know About... Sleep
Can New Neurons Teach an Old Mouse?
The Woman Who Never Forgets
Why We Get Diseases Other Primates Don't
Vital Signs: Trouble in the Nursery
Natural Selections: The Potential Pandemic You've Never Heard Of
20 Things You Didn't Know About... Death
Natural Selections: The Potential Pandemic You've Never Heard Of
Recently Covered in Discover: The Man Who Finds Planets
Sky Lights: The Dark Side of the Universe
20 Things You Didn't Know About... Meteors
Sky Lights: The Dark Side of the Universe
Islam Hits International Space Station
Neighborhood Watch Goes High Tech
Going Atomic... Again
Jaron's World: The Murder of Mystery
How to Make Anything Look Like a Toy, Round II
Raw Data: The Rigorous Study of the Ancient Mariners
Will We Ever Clone a Caveman?
This Month's Ask Discover
How Life Got a Leg Up
Mammals Stake Their Place in Jurassic Park
You Say "Ook Ook," I Say "Aak Aak"
Guilt-Free Gossip for Greens
A Greener Faith
Whatever Happened To... the Exxon Valdez?
Life After Oil
The Next Katrina
  Full access to all site content requires registration as a magazine subscriber.
© 2005 Discover Media LLC. All rights reserved. Reproduction in whole or in part without permission is prohibited.
Privacy Policy / Your California Privacy Rights | Terms and Conditions | Educator's Guide | Subscribe Online Today | Online Media Kit
Customer Care | Contact Us